Review: Wing Jones by Katherine Webber

25909375

Details & Summary:

Title: Wing Jones
Author: Katherine Webber
Publisher: Walker Books
Release Date: January 5th 2017
Pages: 378

Jandy Nelson meets Friday Night Lights: a sweeping story about love and family from an exceptional new voice in YA. With a grandmother from China and another from Ghana, fifteen-year-old Wing Jones is often caught between worlds. But when tragedy strikes, Wing discovers a talent for running she never knew she had. Wing’s speed could bring her family everything it needs. It could also stop Wing getting the one thing she wants.

My thoughts…

The clouds have risen, out of my reach, but now I can see the stars and they wink down at me like they’re saying “You go, girl” and I tilt my head back and smile up at them, and I hope that from way up there my smile looks like a bright shiny star winking back at them.

There’s a lot to like about this book. Wing Jones is one of the most diverse books I’ve read this year with a biracial female protagonist (half-Chinese, half-Ghanese), a black love interest, and several other characters with diverse backgrounds. Story-wise, there’s a lot of focus on athletics, which is nice to see because sports in books are usually associated with male characters. Lastly, I looked forward to reading about a strong brother-sister dynamic, which, again, doesn’t feature in many YA novels. With this many good elements going for it, you’d think Wing Jones would be one of my all-time favourite right? Well… Not exactly.

At first glance, Wing Jones delivers exactly what it promised it would. There’s a lot of diversity (which I loved!), athletics is Wing’s biggest focus, there’s plenty of romance (but not too much) and plenty of brother-sister interactions. We can all agree that these elements would make for a great story.

But there’s one problem: I never connected to the story. After some soul-searching, I realised Wing was my main problem. She’s a great girl who cares deeply about her family, who knows what she wants, and learns to stand up for herself. These are all great qualities…but there’s something missing.

I think what bothers me most is that Wing just so happens to be an amazing runner. There’s very little training or improvements involved. She just started running one night and what do you know, she’s a hidden talent. I understand that people have talents and all that, but the fact that she went from not running at all to beating everyone in every race seemed a little too easy. There were hardly any struggles (running-wise).

Outside of her running, Wing does struggle. Her brother is in a coma, her grandmothers (who stole the show in this book because I loved all their bickering!) are exhausting to be around, and her family has financial problems. On top of that, she’s bullied in school by this one girl, she has to deal with racist comments, and she’s had an unrequited crush on her brother’s best friend for ages. But with all of that going on, I felt she was a little detached and passive sometimes.  

I also didn’t really enjoy the magical realism. Basically, Wing is guided by a lioness and a dragon in this story (representing her background). As in, she can actually see them and she interacts with them. And while it’s a beautiful idea…it’s just not for me. This is 100% my personal opinion though. If you like magical realism, you’ll love this because Webber does a great job at incorporating them in great detail.

Lastly, the pacing felt off. The beginning and middle moved rather slow while the end tried to wrap up every loose end in the space of a few pages.

While Wing Jones seemed to be the perfect book for me, the lack of strong emotions and flawed pacing stopped me from connecting to the main character and the story on a deeper level.

Rating

3 thoughts on “Review: Wing Jones by Katherine Webber

  1. Lovely review, Lauren! I have heard good things about this book so far – in fact, I think I already have it on my TBR, I will have to check. I’m sorry to hear you didn’t fall in love with it and couldn’t connect to the story – it is always a bit annoying when that happens :/ I really like magical realism though, so I’m really curious to read that one 🙂

    Like

  2. Aw, it’s too bad you couldn’t connect to the story very much! It sounded like it had such perfect story elements. It’s kind of frustrating when the main character seems to just have a talent for something, out of nowhere–and especially with running? Like that’s HARD. But I do like magical realism, so I might have to check this out ahah. Lovely review Lauren! ❤

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s